February was quite a social month for Smart Sparrow, as our CEO Dror Ben-Naim was invited to host two Twitter chats, held by EdSurge (@EdSurge) and the WICHE Cooperative for Educational Technologies (@WCET_info) – each on the topic of Adaptive Learning. Both chats provided opportunities to engage the education community in a discussion around this topic. Students, faculty, authors, experts, and other AL thought leaders chimed in to ask questions, share their ideas and connect with one another on the use of adaptive learning, and its role in the future of higher education.
Following the launch of EdSurge’s special report on Adaptive Learning, the team held a Twitter chat, #EdSurgeAL for a deeper dive discussion on all things related to adaptive learning. We were very pleased with the turnout, and the 60-minute discussion that ensued.
A special shoutout to @AdamdFried – we agree that these conversations are critical to building a common language and deeper understanding of what the available #AL tools are and what they can do – then, users can choose!
A1: @DrorBenNaim, Founder & CEO @Smart_Sparrow – a Learning Design Platform for Adaptive Courseware https://t.co/duzcJxgqpI #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
@tytonpartners – Hello from Westport, Ma
— FieldTripZoom (@fieldtripzoom) February 12, 2016
Liz Arney @nsvf on the Innovative Schools team in Oakland, CA. #EdSurgeAL
— Liz Arney (@goblended) February 12, 2016
#EdSurgeAL @pefchattanooga James Snyder, Central High Harrison, TN
— mba04jvs3 (@mba04jvs3) February 12, 2016
In class instruction is the best example of AL
The chat format was in a Q&A style. 10 questions were asked.
1. Adaptive Learning – transformative technology or just another buzzword? Why?
Most of us agree that Adaptive Learning is both powerful and transformative. However, there seemed to be different views as to whether it should empower students, teachers or both.
A1: #adaptivelearning is transformational! Has the potential to personalize learning to student needs https://t.co/RHLxr3yGjB #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
#AdaptiveLearning = (#datascience + #learningscience + #edtech )-powered differentiated instruction #EdSurgeAL
— Angie McAllister PhD (@AngieMcData) February 12, 2016
#EdSurgeAL transformation comes from how it transforms the teacher/student relationship, not the student/tech relationship
— David Porcaro (@DavidPorcaro) February 12, 2016
a bit of both. I think teachers need tools that are easy to use, effective and have potential to transform Teaching & learning. #EdSurgeAL
— Christine Lund (@lundce) February 12, 2016
2. If you think a tool is truly adaptive, what would it do well?
This is a misconception we’ve been seeing over and over again. Tools aren’t adaptive. Learning experiences are. So we actually need to reframe the question: If you think a learning experience is truly adaptive, what would it do well?
A2: An adaptive tool is like an adaptive teacher: modifies approach, emphasis, instruction, feedback & style based on learner #EdSurgeAL
— Ossa Fisher (@ossaf) February 12, 2016
A2: What makes #adaptivelearning great: enabling #ActiveLearning, providing feedback & lesson pathways https://t.co/rJwTPZG5jb #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
A2: Truly adaptive would efficiently diagnose, intervene, measure, provide *targeted* feedback & personalized reassessment. #EdSurgeAL
— Joseph South (@southjoseph) February 12, 2016
3. How comfortable are you with software making instructional decisions for students?
This was a very controversial question. As we know, the AL landscape is quite diverse. Some tools are a black box algorithms putting teachers in the back seat, while others empower them to be in control. The general sentiment was “transparency is the key”.
Q3: For us, software doesn’t make decisions – faculty do! They are in total control of content & pedagogy https://t.co/X83tFOWfF1 #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
@Edtechnerd doesn't matter how comfortable i am; it matters how comfortable teachers are. let them control adaptive features #EdSurgeAL
— Angie McAllister PhD (@AngieMcData) February 12, 2016
Teachers still single most important factor. Without training in AL, we are still lost. @southjoseph @AngieMcData @Paty_Gomes_ #edsurgeal
— Enlearn (@EnlearnOrg) February 12, 2016
A3: Software does NOT make decisions for students, it surfaces data, generates hypotheses. People decide. #EdSurgeAL @declara
— Nelson Gonzalez (@NelsonGonzalez) February 12, 2016
4. What roles should teachers/admins play when it comes to using the tools effectively?
“Teachers must be in charge” was the unanimous answer to question number four. Sigh. Although there is great demand for more support for teachers.
Teachers are at the center, CREATING active & adaptive learning experiences that cater to student needs https://t.co/4kNx3KEa9L #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
@EricGOA I really like that. That means we need to treat teachers like designers and teach them to be builders with legos. #EdSurgeAL
— Christina Quattrocch (@cquattrocchi) February 12, 2016
Nothing can compete with a teacher’s ability to engage students, diagnose misconceptions & inspire learning #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
@EdSurge 1. be a co-design partner 2. learn how it works 3. fine tune to suit your goals/needs 4. measure outcomes holistically #EdSurgeAL
— Angie McAllister PhD (@AngieMcData) February 12, 2016
For every ounce of technology, you need ten ounces of humanity.
— betaclassroom (@betaclassroom) February 12, 2016
Given this ratio, I'm more than #Excited #EDsurgeAL
5. Will students become more active or passive learners as a result of adaptive learning technology? Why?
It depends, just “adaptive” is not enough. Next-gen systems should encourage active learning #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
A5: Way more active than typical worksheets aligned to a pre-determined scope and sequence #EdSurgeAL
— AnirbanBhattacharyya (@AnirbanKIPP) February 12, 2016
A5: If adaptive learning doesn't create more active learners then we have failed. #edsurgeal
— Enlearn (@EnlearnOrg) February 12, 2016
A5 Passive learning is what adaptive tech eradicates. LE are designed bottom-up to meet demands of medium https://t.co/zRevV2nPOF #EdSurgeAL
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
6. Do you think in 10 years adaptive technology will be the standard in our classrooms? Terrified? Exciting?
@EdSurge #EdSurgeAL 10 years - yes. most if not all digital learning experiences would be adaptive. mark my words.
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
A6: Today's adaptive technology will look like yesterday's worksheet in 10 years. #PerdictiveLearning #EdSurgeAL
— Angela Estrella (@am_estrella) February 12, 2016
A6. One sweet day, "adaptive, personalized, individualized...." will be known as plain old "teaching and learning". #edsurgeal
— betaclassroom (@betaclassroom) February 12, 2016
@wtracy #EdSurgeAL this is not ed-reform. This is more like multi-frontal tech-powered assault on the ed status- quo
— Dror Ben-Naim (@DrorBenNaim) February 12, 2016
A summary of the #WCETAdaptive chat can be found here.